Why I Hate the Word “Obedience”

Ian Shivers • January 27, 2026

Share this article

I understand why obedience is so attractive.

I’ve always hated the word obedience. But since becoming a parent, I hate it even more. It’s put a sharp spotlight on something I already felt deep down.

I Don’t Want an “Obedient” Daughter

I want my daughter to grow up:


  • confident


  • curious


  • able to problem solve


  • able to think for herself


  • able to make her own decisions


  • able to question things


  • able to think critically


I don’t want her to blindly follow instructions just because someone tells her to. I don’t want her to think: “Because you said so” is a good reason.



Yes — I need her to listen to me. But blind compliance is not healthy. Raising an “obedient” child won’t set her up for success in life. And it won’t help her become who she really is.


And It’s the Same With Dogs

Just like with my daughter…



Obedience doesn’t even come close to what we actually need from our dogs. Yes — I need dogs to listen. But I don’t want a dog that shuts down. I don’t want a dog that is scared to make choices. I don’t want a dog that only behaves because they fear getting it wrong. That’s not a healthy dog. And it’s not a dog that feels safe.


Behaviour Is Information — Not Disrespect

When my daughter has a meltdown…


I don’t think: “She’s being disobedient.”


I think:


“She’s tired.”
“She’s overwhelmed.”
“She’s hungry.”
“She doesn’t have the skills yet.”


Her behaviour is information. And it’s my job to notice it, assess it, and work with it. Not against it.


Dogs are no different.


When a dog barks, pulls, jumps, freezes, shuts down, or reacts… That behaviour is information. It’s telling us something about:


  • their emotional state


  • their stress level


  • their needs


  • their learning history


  • their environment



It’s not disrespect. It’s communication.


Obedience Ignores the Whole Picture

The word obedience reduces everything down to: “Did you do what I told you to do?”


It ignores:


  • emotional regulation


  • nervous system health


  • stress load


  • fear


  • confusion


  • frustration


  • unmet needs



You can train a dog to sit, stay, and heel… And still have a deeply stressed, anxious, unhappy dog. That’s not success.

What I Care About Instead

I care about:


  • emotional stability


  • healthy regulation


  • communication


  • trust


  • safety


  • cooperation


  • choice within boundaries


I want dogs to:


  • feel safe in their world


  • understand what’s expected


  • trust their caregiver


  • recover quickly from stress


  • be able to make good decisions


  • listen because they feel secure — not scared



That’s a completely different goal to obedience.


I Want Dialogue, Not Control

With my daughter, I aim for:


  • guidance


  • explanation


  • consistency


  • kindness


  • clear boundaries


  • emotional support


Not power struggles.


Not fear.


Not “because I said so.”


And with dogs, it’s the same.


Training should feel like a conversation.


Not a command system.


Not a battle.



Not a dominance contest.


Listening Matters — But It’s Not the Goal

Of course dogs need to listen. Of course we need safety, structure, and rules. But listening is a by-product of a healthy relationship. Not the foundation of it. When dogs feel:


  • safe


  • understood


  • supported


  • regulated


  • guided clearly



They listen more. Not because they have to. But because it makes sense to.


The Takeaway

I don’t want obedient dogs. I want:


  • emotionally healthy dogs


  • confident dogs


  • regulated dogs


  • dogs who trust their humans


  • dogs who feel safe enough to think and choose well



Obedience is shallow. Relationship is deep. And deep is what actually lasts.


If you’d like help applying this and in doing so, improving your and your dogs lives, I can support you in a few different ways.

Through Canine Caregivers, I offer online courses and webinars to build understanding, structure, and consistency at your pace.

If you’re based in Sydney, I also offer 1:1 training across Sydney, socialisation and puppy classes, and can provide all recommended training equipment to support the work we’re doing.

I offer The Complete Care training program that covers every single base you will need as well as The Starter Program which allows you to tailor the training and support you need with flexibility.

— Ian

 Bondi Behaviourist


“A healthy dog is a happy dog and a happy dog is great to live with”.

I understand why obedience is so attractive.

Ian Shivers

Pet Parent, Dog Trainer & Behaviourist, podcast and content writer

I’m not here to help you create an obedient dog. I’m here to help you create a better life with your dog built on understanding, trust, and meeting both of your needs.


Whether you’re starting fresh with a new puppy or looking to improve life with your current dog, I’m here to guide you with practical, simple, and effective support.


Hi, my name is Ian, and I’ve been working with dogs and their owners since 2007, helping families build calmer, more connected relationships that last. With 150+ five-star Google reviews, I’m proud to be one of Sydney’s highest-rated behaviourists you can trust.

Table of Content

Get Your Free Starter Guide

Trusted by over 4,000 puppy owners, rescue dog owners and owners of dogs with behaviour issues across Sydney.

Ebook - The complete dog training framework

Webinar - A deep dive into the dog training framework

Dog Training Blog

Discounts on Lyka Pet Food

Recent Posts

By Bondi Behaviourist September 16, 2026
The ball is not the problem. How you play it and where you play it are. A structured game builds thinking, and the dog park is the wrong place for it.
By Bondi Behaviourist September 7, 2026
Most dog advice online is generic and contradictory. TRACE the AI Dog Trainer is built on one behaviourist’s methodology, monitored by a human, and knows when to refer you on.
By Bondi Behaviourist September 2, 2026
One dog met fifty others growing up and still couldn’t cope. Socialisation is about breadth and quality, not the number of dogs your dog has met.
By Bondi Behaviourist August 25, 2026
One label never captures a dog. Confidence, sensitivity, and recovery style move independently — and reading only one is why plans quietly fail.
By Bondi Behaviourist August 18, 2026
Putting your dog in situations they’re not ready for doesn’t build tolerance. It builds sensitivity. Real progress happens in the work that comes before the situation.
By Bondi Behaviourist August 11, 2026
The answer isn’t always remove them. It depends on whether your dog is uncomfortable or distressed — and that difference matters more than any rule.
By Bondi Behaviourist August 5, 2026
Perfect is the wrong target in dog training. Better is. And when life goes sideways, good habits are what get you through it and back on track.
By Bondi Behaviourist July 7, 2026
Pushing for exciting dog interactions before the foundation is there can build unpredictable associations. Good socialisation starts with calm, not play.
By Bondi Behaviourist June 30, 2026
Letting your dog run 100 metres ahead into a group of unknown dogs removes you from every decision that matters. Here’s why proximity is the point.
By Bondi Behaviourist June 23, 2026
Fetch looks like fun. But compulsive fetch depletes dopamine baselines, spikes cortisol, and can quietly make your dog harder to settle — not easier.
Show More