Who Should Be Walking Your Dog?
Who Should Be Walking Your Dog?
A toddler was walking a dog around a playground on the weekend. Somewhere between two and three years old.
He had the lead in his hand and no adult anywhere near him. His parents were on the other side of the park, chatting with other parents, with no idea where either of them had got to.
The dog was an old dachshund walking with a very poor gait. The kind of gait that usually means spinal pain.
I watched that for a while and it made me deeply uncomfortable.
What that dog was actually dealing with
Start with the body. An old dog with spinal pain being towed around a playground, physically hating every second of it.
He was on a collar, and the toddler was holding the lead up high. So his head was being held up tight the entire time.
Then the behaviour. He was scanning constantly. Visibly stressed and anxious.
He kept trying to get back to the family, over and over, and he wasn’t allowed to go.
And then the setting. This was happening in among other children who had never met this dog, who kept coming over to pat him. He hated that too.
A dog in pain. Strangers crowding him. No ability to leave. Nobody supervising.
We were all very lucky that dog didn’t bite somebody that day.
The toddler, by the way, was doing nothing wrong. He was being a toddler. The adults put him there.
The second one that weekend
A family was sitting and a six-year-old girl had the lead.
The dog kept trying to leave, because he didn’t want to be there.
So she lifted the lead. Both front paws came off the ground, and she held him there to stop him going anywhere.
That is what six-year-olds do. It is not a character flaw. Children solve problems like children.
She should never have had the lead in the first place, let alone with nobody watching.
Think about everything sitting in that one moment. A child who could be pulled over. A dog in pain, anxious and cornered. Other kids within reach. One bite and the consequences are serious for everybody, including the dog.
The question underneath it
Those two scenes got me onto a bigger question, and it is one worth asking properly.
Who should be walking your dog?
Children holding the lead unsupervised is the obvious version. But it comes up constantly in far less dramatic forms, and most people never stop to weigh it.
When someone else is minding your dog
Here is one I get asked about a lot. A family knows their dog and walks them regularly. They go away and leave the dog in someone else’s care.
Should that person walk the dog?
It depends, and these are the variables I would actually weigh.
Does your dog have behaviour issues? Are they stressed or anxious generally, and are they stressed or anxious specifically in this person’s care?
Where is this person going to take them? Can they set your dog up to succeed? What is that walk going to look like, and is any of it familiar to your dog?
Because this is the bit that gets missed. Someone who doesn’t know your dog well won’t read them as quickly. They won’t respond in a familiar way.
So if your dog does get uncomfortable out there, the support they get will not be the support they are used to.
Walks are not automatically good
This is the assumption worth dismantling. A walk is not inherently wonderful for a dog. Some walks are awful for them.
If your dog goes out and spends the whole time barking, pulling, stressed and desperate, that is not an enriching part of their day.
You are not bringing anything good to the table by making them go through it.
So if that is what the walk is going to look like in someone else’s hands, the answer is no.
Leave the dog in their care and have them do something else entirely. A game your dog likes. Company. Support. Time at home with someone kind.
The hotel gym
I go on holiday with excellent intentions. I am going to get up before the family and use the hotel gym.
Sometimes I do. Mostly I don’t. I do nowhere near as much exercise on holiday as I do the rest of the year.
And it is quite nice. I miss it a little, and then I get home and pick it back up.
A fortnight of your dog’s life does not have to look like all the others.
Missing their usual exercise for two weeks is mildly frustrating for them. A fortnight of bad walks producing stress, fear, anxiety and possible harm to themselves or someone else is a completely different cost.
It isn’t worth it. If the person minding your dog cannot look after them in a way that keeps them comfortable out there, don’t send them out.
Your dog walker counts too
The same question applies to someone you are paying, and I have had this with clients recently.
One dog doesn’t much enjoy socialising with other dogs, and was being sent out on a group walk several times a week. That is not in their best interest, however good the walker is with the others.
Another dog struggles with compulsive behaviour, and the walker brings a ball every single time and won’t change the routine.
So should that dog keep going out with them?
The only thing that matters here is whether it actually meets your dog’s needs.
Be careful who you send your dog out with. It is a significant part of their week. Done well it is real enrichment. Done badly it is quietly eroding their wellbeing and their behaviour.
You can end up paying somebody to make your problem worse.
With a reactive dog, this matters more
If your dog is reactive, stressed or anxious, the whole job is managing their stress levels and managing how often they get to practise the behaviour you are trying to change.
Every outing either builds toward that or works against it.
Which means an outing with the wrong person, in the wrong place, is not neutral. It is a setback you paid for or arranged.
And if that means keeping your dog in your own care, because you don’t currently have the people in your life who can do this properly, then that is the right call.
Don’t send them out for the sake of it. Don’t send them out just to get them out of the house.
It has to be appropriate, it has to build toward what you are trying to achieve, and it certainly shouldn’t be making things worse.
If you don’t have the right people yet
That last point leaves a lot of owners stuck, and it is worth saying what to do about it.
Most people reading this don’t have a friend who can read their reactive dog accurately, pick the right route, and respond the way they would themselves.
That is not a personal failing. It is a skill, and almost nobody has it by accident.
It is also learnable, which is why I am running reactive dog classes in the new year.
A controlled environment, dogs who have been assessed, and the handling skills that make the difference between an outing that helps and one that sets you back.
The point is not just a better walk on the day. It is you becoming the person who can read your own dog and make the right call out there, every time.
Because the honest answer to who should be walking your dog is: somebody who can actually see what your dog is telling them.
Nobody in that playground could.
If any of this sounds like you and your dog but you don't know how to change things, here's how else I can help.
Through Canine Caregivers, I offer online courses and webinars to build understanding, structure, and consistency at your pace.
If you’re based in Sydney, I also offer 1:1 training across Sydney, socialisation classes, and can provide all recommended training equipment to support the work we’re doing.
I offer The Complete Care training program that covers every single base you will need as well as The Starter Program which allows you to tailor the training and support you need with flexibility.
Ask TRACE The AI Dog Trainer trained by me personally 10 free questions at any time
Or get in touch for 1:1 help in Sydney
— Ian
Bondi Behaviourist
“A healthy dog is a happy dog and a happy dog is great to live with”.

Ian Shivers
Pet Parent, Dog Trainer & Behaviourist, podcast and content writer
I’m not here to help you create an obedient dog. I’m here to help you create a better life with your dog built on understanding, trust, and meeting both of your needs.
Whether you’re starting fresh with a new puppy or looking to improve life with your current dog, I’m here to guide you with practical, simple, and effective support.
Hi, my name is Ian, and I’ve been working with dogs and their owners since 2007, helping families build calmer, more connected relationships that last. With 150+ five-star Google reviews, I’m proud to be one of Sydney’s highest-rated behaviourists you can trust.
Table of Content
Get Your Free Starter Guide
Trusted by over 4,000 puppy owners, rescue dog owners and owners of dogs with behaviour issues across Sydney.
Ebook - The complete dog training framework
Webinar - A deep dive into the dog training framework
Dog Training Blog
Discounts on Lyka Pet Food











